When Does Replant Corn Pay?

by Bill Mahanna and Ev Thomas

It may seem a bit premature to be discussing replant decisions in February, but having this information at your fingertips come April or May could alleviate considerable frustration. The current lack of feed inventory in many geographies coupled with the high price of grain makes replant decisions more critical than ever.

Corn can face many different stresses capable of reducing stands, such as cold, wet or flooded soils, bird or insect feeding, hail or even a spring frost. In cases of severe stand reduction, growers will need to determine if replanting will be more profitable than sticking with the current crop.

THE REPLANT WINDOW FOR CORN can be quite narrow. Even though corn is a crucial ration ingredient, as the growing season progresses the decision to plant another crop instead of corn may make better sense.

Assessing the stand

The first step in a replant decision is assessing the current stand by evaluating the number of lost or injured plants. For hail or spring frost events, it is best to wait a few days to allow time to see how plants recover. In cases of early season flooding, corn prior to the V5-V6 growth stage can survive for two to four days in saturated soils.

However, warm temperatures can shorten this survival time to only 24 hours. Also evaluate stand uniformity . . . such as frequent long gaps in the rows. An uneven stand will yield less than a relatively even stand with the same number of plants.

Stand counts should be taken randomly across the entire area being considered for replant. The accuracy of stand estimates logically improve with the number of locations sampled. The accepted method of stand counts is to sample one one-thousandth of an acre (Table 1). Measure off the distance appropriate for the row width, count the number of live plants and multiply by 1,000 to obtain an estimate of plants per acre.

Table 1. Corn stand estimates: row lengths equal to 1/1000th of an acre
Row width Length of row
38 inches 13 feet 9 inches
36 inches 14 feet 6 inches
30 inches 17 feet 5 inches
22 inches 23 feet 9 inches
20 inches 26 feet 2 inches
15 inches 34 feet 10 inches

How are plants doing?

Once you've determined the surviving plant stand, check the health of the plants. Plants that are severely injured or defoliated will be poor doers due to reduced photosynthetic capability and result in a lower yield. Also, check if the plant tissue at the growing point is a healthy white or cream color with normal texture.

For evaluating frost damage to corn plants 6 inches or less in height, use a knife to cut some frosted plants off about 1 inch above the soil. If the plant is still alive, you will see the new growth in a matter of hours, certainly within one day. The center of the cut plant grows the fastest, so you will observe a pyramid shape where just hours before there was a flat cut surface.

On a positive note, weed control is typically improved with later plantings due to tillage effects on germinated weeds and improved seedling vigor due to warmer soils. On the flip side, later plantings may incur more feeding from second-generation corn borers and silk feeding by rootworm beetles.

Once a stand has been evaluated, the expected yield can be compared to expected replant yield (Table 2). In general, the table shows that Midwest corn yield potential goes up with greater stand populations until the optimum of 35,000 plants per acre. Likewise it declines with planting dates later than April 20 and earlier than April 10 based on University of Illinois research.

Table 2. Plant population and planting date responses for corn yield
Planting Date Plant population (1,000 plants/acre)
  10 15 20 26 30 35 40
  % of maximum yield
April 1 54 68 78 88 95 99 99
April 10 57 70 81 91 97 100 100
April 20 58 71 81 91 97 100 99
April 30 58 70 80 89 95 97 96
May 9 55 68 77 86 91 93 91
May 19 50 63 72 80 85 86 84
May 29 44 56 65 73 77 78 75
June 8 35 47 56 63 67 67 64
Source: University of Illinois

Other factors such as fuel, labor, equipment, previous weed control applications, seed cost, availability and cost of feed alternatives, insurance compensation and average first frost dates need to be factored into whether replanting will result in an economically sound decision. Land grant universities are a good source of recommended maturity of corn hybrids for different planting dates across relative maturity zones.

If there’s a delay

If replanting is delayed past a reasonable time for corn to mature, it may be more economical to consider soybeans (after June 1 in Wisconsin for example) or forage sorghum, sudangrass or sorghum-sudan crosses which can be planted into July.

As with all cropping decisions, working with your seed sales professional or consulting agronomist will help bring a clearer picture to any replant decision. That conversation will need to include a frank discussion about your farm's feed inventory and future needs.


Used by permission from the February 10, 2013, issue of Hoard's Dairyman.
Copyright 2013 by W.D. Hoard & Sons Company, Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin.

Close this Tab

Weather Dashboard

See All | Customize

The latest data for your fields at-a-glance.

Today's Forecast
Time Temp Precip Wind
5-Day Forecast
Date Low High
Close this Tab

Markets Dashboard

See All | Customize

The latest data for your fields at-a-glance

Commodity Futures

Quotes delayed 20 minutes.
Commodity Price Change Last Updated
Commodity Futures Feed Not Available
Quotes delayed 20 minutes. Data provided by FutureSource

Local Cash Markets

Commodity Price Basis Last Updated
Local Cash Market Feed Not Available