Putting Variable-Rate Seeding to Work on Your Farm

Crop Insights written by Mark Jeschke, Ph.D.1, Paul Carter, Ph.D.2, Phil Bax3, and Ryan Schon4

 

Summary

  • Extensive field research has documented the value of planting higher corn seeding rates in more productive field areas and decreasing rates where productivity is lower.
  • To maximize variable-rate seeding (VRS) value, appropriate crop management zones, or Decision Zones, must be defined. When available, Decision Zones can include soil types, topography, irrigation, and long-term yield history. In some cases, other information like soil EC can also be used.
  • DuPont Pioneer researchers conduct thousands of population trials at hundreds of locations across North America. Data from these trials provide the basis for seeding rate recommendations for each Decision Zone.
  • Appropriate differences between seeding rates is field-specific and depends on the capabilities of the planting equipment, yield targets, field variability, soil productivity and understanding of hybrid specific interaction of genotype by environment. Agronomically, seeding rates should differ by at least 4,000 seeds/acre.
  • DuPont Pioneer provides EncircaSM Yield Stand variable-rate seeding recommendations through Encirca certified services agents and Pioneer sales professionals. Prescriptions can be emailed, exported to a storage device, or sent wirelessly to equipment with enabled wireless data transfer capabilities.
     
    A growing number of VRS-enabled corn planters allows for more widespread implementation of variable-rate seeding strategies.

    A growing number of VRS-enabled corn planters allows for more widespread implementation of variable-rate seeding strategies. (Planter image courtesy of CaseIH.)

Introduction

Each year, an increasing number of farmers are utilizing planters with variable-rate seeding (VRS) capability, and more farmers report putting this feature to work to vary corn and soybean seeding rates. Those using the technology expect it to help increase yields as well as maximize the value of their seed investment.

The growing number of VRS-enabled planters and widespread on-farm use of GPS technology make it easier than ever to deploy a VRS strategy. However, growers still need to understand the variability within their fields and implement the appropriate hybrid-specific seeding rates. This Crop Insights discusses guidelines for developing a VRS strategy, designating management zones, selecting seeding rates, and implementing a field prescription.

Developing a Variable-Rate Strategy

Growers new to VRS may benefit by collaborating with someone knowledgeable in this area, such as an Encirca certified services agent or Pioneer sales professional.

The first step in developing a VRS strategy is to identify candidate fields.

Creating Decision Zones
Creating Decision Zones within a field is based on the following (Figure 1):
  • Grower knowledge of yield history, cropping history, and general productivity of field areas
  • Environmental Response Units (ERUs) based on soil type, topography, landscape, slope, and drainage
  • Yield history based on multiple years of harvest data
  • Crop productivity ratings based on soil type, if yield history is not available
  • Irrigated and dryland areas of fields, if appropriate
Decision Zones can also sometimes include
  • Soil electrical conductivity and/or soil color
  • Remote imagery to determine NDVI, bare soil, crop vigor

The grower is best qualified to identify management zones that will be predictive from year to year, based on trends that are historically consistent. For example, low-lying field areas may perform best in dry years and poorly in wet years, and the grower is most familiar with how to best manage such nuances.

Decision Zones incorporate a field's historical yield data and management layers to segment and improve the precision of the soil productivity zones.

Figure 1. Decision Zones incorporate a field’s historical yield data and management layers to segment and improve the precision of the soil productivity zones.

Selecting a Hybrid and Seeding Rates

Selecting a Hybrid

The next step is selecting the proper corn hybrid for the field, taking into account the range of possible growing conditions and resulting yield potential of field areas. Your local Pioneer sales professional is a valuable resource to help identify the right product for your growing environment.

Selecting Seeding Rates

DuPont Pioneer scientists conduct thousands of field research trials at hundreds of locations annually across North America to help understand grain yield response to planting rate for Pioneer® brand hybrids. In addition, many growers have their own data on variable planting rates gathered from as-planted and yield data. Decades of DuPont Pioneer research have shown that corn yield response to seeding rate within a commercially-relevant range can usually be well-described by a quadratic function. Grain yield will increase with seeding rate up to an optimum point and then decline as seeding rate is increased above the optimum due to a higher rate of barrenness and extended anthesis-silking intervals (Jeschke et al., 2009). The optimum seeding rate can vary based on hybrid genetics. Figure 2 shows an example of quadratic response functions for 2 hybrid families with the same CRM that have been shown to differ in their response to plant population in Pioneer research trials.

Corn yield response to plant population of 2 Pioneer brand hybrid families with similar comparative relative maturity.

Figure 2. Corn yield response to plant population of 2 Pioneer brand hybrid families with similar comparative relative maturity.

Seeding Rate Response to Productivity

Yield response to seeding rate by productivity level is the critical factor for creating variable-rate seeding prescriptions. The population required to maximize yield increases as yield level increases. When grouped by yield level, results from Pioneer plant population trials showed that the economic optimum seeding rate increased from approximately 31,000 seeds/acre at the 150 bu/acre yield level to over 39,000 seeds/acre at the 240 bu/acre yield level (Figure 3). An Iowa State University study comparing corn yield response to plant population across soils with different corn suitability ratings found similar results. The most productive soils tended to have a higher optimum population for maximum yield (Woli et al., 2014).

The increase in optimum seeding rate by yield level has been shown to be roughly linear within the range represented by research data (Figure 3).

Corn grain yield response to seeding rate at 9 yield levels, 2009-2014.

Figure 3. Corn grain yield response to seeding rate at 9 yield levels, 2009-2014. Dots indicate the economic optimum seeding rate within each yield level.
Economic optimum seeding rates based on a seed cost of $3.50/1,000 seeds and corn grain price of $4.00/bu.

Economic and Agronomic Optimum Rates

It is important to note that suggested seeding rates produced via the DuPont Pioneer Planting Rate Estimator and EncircaSM Yield Stand are based on economic optimum rates that consider both the revenue from yield and the cost of additional seed. This provides the most useful information for optimizing return on seed investment. When comparing recommendations from different companies, farmers need to understand the economic and genetic assumptions that affect each recommendation.

Building a Variable-Rate Seeding Prescription

  • Working with an Encirca certified services agent or Pioneer sales professional, assign Decision Zone yield targets for each field. Decision Zones are typically defined by soil properties, topography, yield history, and irrigation management.
  • Select each Pioneer® brand corn product and review the suggested seeding rates. Select any additional hybrids or varieties and seeding rates. Encirca Yield Stand prescriptions will be ready to review and edit (Figure 4).
  • Review each prescription in Encirca Yield Stand and make any Decision Zone specific edits to seeding rates. Encirca Yield Stand conveniently generates prescriptions for every product, for every field to maximize flexibility when conditions or product changes occur during the planting season.
  • Prescriptions can be received via email and copied to a storage device or uploaded wirelessly to capable monitors.
  • Review planter monitor settings for user preferences and default settings (out of bounds rate, loss of signal rate, offset distance, etc.). Make sure the controller is set to record as-planted information! Upload the as-planted data to the EncircaSM services software platform for further analysis.

Example of variable-rate seeding prescription map in Encirca(SM) Yield Stand.
 
Example of variable-rate seeding prescription map in Encirca(SM) Yield Stand.

Figure 4. Examples of variable-rate seeding prescription maps in EncircaSM Yield Stand.

Evaluating Variable-Rate Seeding Prescription Effectiveness

Setting up Checks

The recommended best practice for evaluating the effectiveness of VRS prescriptions is planting check strips at rates higher and rates lower than the prescribed rates for the rest of the Decision Zone. These checks can help farmers understand those areas where they might be able to increase yields through higher seeding rates or decrease seeding rates where lower productivity doesn’t typically support higher yields.

Strips are typically field-length strips of a single planting rate that pass through several management zones. A strip should be placed so that it crosses management zones of most or all other rates. There should be at least 1 strip for each designated seeding rate. Strips are typically 1 planter pass wide. Check strips can be created as part of the prescription and can also be accomplished from the planter monitor in the field.

Blocks are an alternate approach where generally square blocks of higher and lower planting rates are located within different management zones. Their utility is decreasing as growers strive to differentially manage smaller and smaller areas of fields.

In-Season Monitoring

After stand establishment, take stand counts in the different planting rate zones and check areas (e.g. strips). It is important to verify that target populations were actually attained to assure the validity of the test. Pay special attention to high stress areas such as poorly drained spots or high crop residue areas.

Interpreting the Results

  • Work with your Encirca certified services agent or Pioneer sales professional to analyze your yield results.
  • Did higher seeding rates produce greater yields in higher productivity Decision Zones? What impact did weather play? What do you want to do differently next season?
  • Evaluate profitability by comparing yields and accounting for seed costs for any 2 rates in question.

Sources and Additional Resources

Butzen, S. and M. Burnison. 2014. Corn Seeding Rate Considerations for 2014. Crop Insights. Vol. 24. No. 3. DuPont Pioneer.

Doerge, T., M. Jeschke, and P Carter. 2015. Planting Outcome Effects on Corn Yield. Crop Insights. Vol 25, No. 1. DuPont Pioneer.

Jeschke, M., S. Paszkiewicz, and J. Mathesius. 2009. Corn Performance at Very High Plant Populations. Field Facts. Vol. 9, No. 15. DuPont Pioneer.

Woli, K.P., C.L. Burras, L.J. Abendroth, and R.W. Elmore. 2014. Optimizing corn seeding rates using a field’s corn suitability rating. Agron. J. 106:1523-1532.


1 Agronomy Information Manager, DuPont Pioneer
2 Sr. Agronomy Sciences Manager, DuPont Pioneer
3 Product Owner Encirca Services, DuPont Pioneer
4 Sr Manager, Encirca Services, Marketing, DuPont Pioneer

The foregoing is provided for informational use only. EncircaSM services provide estimates and management suggestions based on statistical and agronomic models. Encirca services are not a substitute for sound field monitoring and management practices. Individual results may vary and are subject to a variety of factors, including weather, disease and pest pressure, soil type, and management practices. Encirca services are provided subject to the terms and conditions of purchase which are part of the purchase documents.

F71F86E6-406F-9711-7FE0-2DA3D30957CA

PIONEER® brand products are provided subject to the terms and conditions of purchase which are part of the labeling and purchase documents.
 

91D88F98-9171-B014-4BF4-471E60C7F37D
 
 
Weather
Close this Tab

Weather Dashboard

See All | Customize

The latest data for your fields at-a-glance

Today's Forecast
Time Temp Precip Wind
5-Day Forecast
Date Low High
Markets
Close this Tab

Markets Dashboard

See All | Customize

The latest data for your fields at-a-glance

Commodity Futures

Quotes delayed 20 minutes.
Commodity Price Change Last Updated
Commodity Futures Feed Not Available
Quotes delayed 20 minutes. Data provided by FutureSource

Local Cash Markets

Commodity Price Basis Last Updated
Local Cash Market Feed Not Available